Buying an established business can be an exciting way to become a business owner or expand your existing portfolio. However, it’s crucial to understand the different ways you can structure the purchase, as this can have significant legal, financial, and operational implications. When buying a business, you generally have two main options: an asset sale or a share sale.
In an asset sale, you purchase specific assets and liabilities of the business, such as equipment, inventory, and customer contracts. In a share sale, you acquire ownership of the company itself by purchasing shares from the existing shareholders. Choosing between an asset sale and a share sale is a critical decision that requires careful consideration of factors such as tax consequences, liability exposure, and the transfer of key contracts and employees. This article will explore the key differences between asset sales and share sales, helping you make an informed decision when buying a business in Australia.
What is an Asset Sale?
When you buy a business through an asset sale, you are purchasing specific liabilities and assets of the business rather than acquiring the entire legal entity. This allows you to cherry-pick the parts of the business you want to acquire while leaving behind any unwanted assets or liabilities.
Definition of an Asset Sale
An asset sale involves the transfer of ownership of specific business assets from the seller to the buyer. These assets can include:
- Equipment and machinery
- Inventory and stock
- Intellectual property, such as trademarks, patents, and copyrights
- Customer lists and contracts
- Real estate and leases
- Business licences and permits
In an asset sale, the seller retains ownership of the legal entity, while the buyer purchases the agreed-upon assets and assumes the specified liabilities.
Example of an Asset Sale Transaction
Let’s consider a hypothetical example of a fitness centre to illustrate an asset sale. In this scenario, the buyer, Alex, chooses to purchase the gym as a business rather than buying the company that owns the gym.
Alex will acquire the assets and liabilities directly related to the gym’s operations, such as:
- Exercise equipment and machines
- Inventory, including workout supplements and merchandise
- Customer lists and membership contracts
- Contracts with suppliers or employees
- Leasehold improvements and the lease for the gym’s premises
In this asset sale transaction, Alex has more control over which assets they want to acquire and can avoid taking on any broader legal or financial obligations that might exist at the company level. However, Alex may still need to address any outstanding debts or legal obligations associated directly with the gym’s operations.
By purchasing the gym’s assets, Alex can tailor the acquisition to their specific needs and goals while minimising exposure to unknown liabilities. However, they may need to renegotiate contracts with customers, suppliers, and employees, as these agreements will not automatically transfer with the assets.
Advantages and Disadvantages of an Asset Sale
Asset sales offer several benefits for buyers, including:
- Greater control over the assets and liabilities acquired
- Reduced exposure to unknown or undisclosed liabilities
- Ability to cherry-pick desired assets and leave behind unwanted ones
- Potential tax advantages, such as the ability to allocate the purchase price to specific assets for depreciation purposes
- Flexibility to negotiate which contracts and leases to assume
By selectively purchasing assets, buyers can limit their risk and tailor the acquisition to their specific needs and goals.
Despite the advantages, asset sales also have some drawbacks, such as:
- Need for third-party consents: Transferring contracts, leases, and licences may require the consent of third parties, which can be time-consuming and complex.
- Potential loss of certain assets: Some assets, such as government licences and permits, may not be transferable, requiring the buyer to apply for new ones.
- Disruption to business continuity: Customers and suppliers may need to sign new contracts with the buyer, which can lead to disruptions in the business’s operations.
- Higher transaction costs: Asset sales often involve more extensive due diligence and legal documentation, resulting in higher transaction costs compared to share sales.
While asset sales provide buyers with greater control and reduced liability exposure, they also come with unique challenges that must be carefully navigated to ensure a smooth transition of ownership.
What is a Share Sale?
In a share sale, the buyer acquires ownership of the company that operates the business by purchasing shares from the existing shareholders. This means that the buyer takes control of the entire legal entity, including all its assets, liabilities, and contractual obligations.
Definition of a Share Sale
A share sale involves the transfer of ownership of a company’s shares from the existing shareholders to the buyer. The key characteristics of a share sale include:
- Transfer of company ownership: The buyer becomes a shareholder in the company, effectively taking control of the business.
- Acquisition of all assets and liabilities: The company’s assets and liabilities remain within the legal entity and are not individually transferred to the buyer.
- Continuity of contracts and licences: Existing contracts, leases, and licences remain valid and do not require renegotiation or transfer, as the legal entity remains unchanged.
In a share sale, the buyer steps into the shoes of the previous owner, assuming responsibility for the company’s past, present, and future obligations.
Share Sale Transaction Example
To illustrate a share sale, let’s revisit the hypothetical example of Alex buying a fitness centre. In this scenario, Alex chooses to purchase the shares of the company that owns the gym.
The target company has 100 shares in total, with Bob and Mary each owning 50 shares. Alex purchases all 100 shares, taking over complete ownership of the company. As a result:
- Alex becomes the sole shareholder of the company that owns the gym.
- All assets, including equipment, inventory, and intellectual property, remain with the company and are now under Alex’s control.
- Existing contracts with customers, suppliers, and employees continue uninterrupted, as the legal entity operating the gym remains the same.
- Alex assumes responsibility for all liabilities associated with the company, including any outstanding debts, legal disputes, or tax obligations.
By acquiring the shares, Alex gains control over the entire business without the need to individually transfer assets or renegotiate contracts. However, thorough due diligence is crucial to identify and assess any potential risks or liabilities associated with the company before proceeding with the share purchase.
Advantages of a Share Sale for the Buyer
Buying the shares in the company offer several potential benefits for buyers, such as:
- Smooth transition: By acquiring the company shares, the buyer can ensure a seamless transition of ownership, minimising disruptions to business operations and relationships with customers, suppliers, and employees.
- Preservation of contracts and licences: Existing contracts, leases, and licences remain valid, eliminating the need for renegotiation or transfer.
- Potential tax advantages: In some cases, a share sale may provide tax benefits, such as the ability to utilise the company’s existing tax losses to offset future profits.
- Increased financing opportunities: Acquiring an established company with a proven track record may make it easier for the buyer to secure financing from banks and lenders.
However, buyers must also be aware of the potential drawbacks associated with share sales, as discussed in the following section.
Risks of a Share Sale for the Buyer
Share sales come with inherent risks for buyers, which must be carefully evaluated and mitigated:
- Assumption of unknown liabilities: By acquiring the company shares, the buyer inherits all of the liabilities of the company, including any undisclosed or contingent liabilities that may not be immediately apparent.
- Complexity of due diligence: Share sales typically require more extensive and thorough due diligence to uncover potential risks and liabilities, which can be time-consuming and costly.
- Potential for hidden issues: Despite comprehensive due diligence, there may be hidden problems or liabilities that could materialise after the sale, such as pending legal disputes, tax issues, or regulatory non-compliance.
- Dependence on seller’s warranties and indemnities: To mitigate risks, buyers often require the seller to provide extensive warranties and indemnities. However, the effectiveness of these protections depends on the seller’s financial capacity to honour them.
Given the potential risks involved, buyers must work closely with legal, financial, and tax advisors to structure the share purchase agreement and ensure appropriate protections are in place to minimise exposure to unforeseen liabilities.
Need Answers Fast?
Contact us today.
Key Factors to Consider When Choosing Between an Asset Sale vs Share Sale
When deciding between an asset sale and a share sale, buyers must carefully evaluate several key factors to determine the most suitable approach for their specific situation. These factors include due diligence requirements, tax and stamp duty implications, treatment of existing employees, and assignability of key contracts.
Due Diligence Requirements for Asset Sale vs Share Sale
The nature and extent of due diligence that may be required can vary significantly between asset sales and share sales:
- Asset sales: Due diligence in an asset sale typically focuses on verifying the ownership, condition, and transferability of the specific assets being acquired. This process may involve reviewing titles, liens, and encumbrances on assets, as well as assessing the validity and assignability of contracts and licences.
- Share sales: Share sales generally require more comprehensive and extensive due diligence, as the buyer is acquiring the entire company, including all its assets, liabilities, and obligations. This process may involve a thorough examination of the company’s financial records, tax returns, legal documents, employee contracts, and customer agreements. Buyers may also need to assess potential risks and liabilities, such as pending lawsuits, environmental issues, or regulatory compliance matters.
The complexity and scope of due diligence in a share sale can be significantly greater than in an asset sale, as buyers must ensure they have a complete understanding of the company’s overall financial health and potential exposure to risks.
Tax and Stamp Duty Implications in Australia
Tax and stamp duty considerations can play a significant role in determining the optimal structure for a business acquisition in Australia:
- Asset sales: In an asset sale, buyers may be subject to stamp duty on the transfer of certain assets, such as real property and business goodwill. However, buyers may also benefit from tax advantages, such as the ability to allocate the purchase price to specific assets for depreciation purposes. Sellers in an asset sale may face higher tax liabilities, as they do not qualify for certain capital gains tax (CGT) concessions available in share sales.
- Share sales: Share sales generally do not attract stamp duty, as the transfer of shares is typically exempt. However, buyers in a share sale may inherit the company’s existing tax liabilities and may not be able to claim depreciation on the acquired assets. Sellers in a share sale may benefit from CGT concessions, such as the 50% discount for individuals and trusts, which can result in significant tax savings.
The specific tax and stamp duty implications will depend on the jurisdiction, the nature of the assets being transferred, and the structure of the transaction. It is essential for both buyers and sellers to consult with tax experts to assess the potential tax consequences and optimise the transaction structure accordingly.
Treatment of Existing Employees in Business Sales
The way in which existing employees are treated can differ significantly between asset sales and share sales:
- Asset sales: In an asset sale, the buyer has the flexibility to choose which employees they wish to retain and can negotiate new employment contracts with those individuals. However, this process can be disruptive to the business and may result in the loss of key personnel. Buyers may also be required to provide notice of termination to employees under applicable workplace laws and may have to make redundancy payments.
- Share sales: In a share sale, existing employment contracts generally remain in place, as the legal entity employing the staff remains unchanged. This continuity can be beneficial for maintaining stability and retaining key employees. However, buyers inherit all employee liabilities and obligations, including any potential disputes or claims.
Buyers should carefully consider the potential impact on employees and assess the associated risks and costs when deciding between an asset sale and a share sale.
Assignability of Key Contracts
The ability to transfer key contracts, such as leases, licences, and supply agreements, can be a critical factor in choosing between an asset sale and a share sale:
- Asset sales: In an asset sale, the buyer must obtain the consent of third parties to assign or novate contracts to the new owner. This process can be time-consuming and may require negotiations with each counterparty. In some cases, certain contracts or licences may not be transferable, which could impact the value or viability of the acquisition.
- Share sales: In a share sale, contracts generally remain in place with the company, as the legal entity has not changed. This continuity can be advantageous for maintaining key relationships and minimising disruptions to the business. However, some contracts may contain change of control provisions that could be triggered by a share sale, requiring the buyer to obtain consent or renegotiate terms.
The assignability of key contracts is an important consideration for buyers, as it can impact the smooth transition of the business and the realisation of anticipated synergies and benefits from the acquisition.
Speak to a Lawyer Today
We call back within 24 hours.
Conclusion
Buying or selling a business involves navigating complex legal and financial considerations. Whether you’re purchasing business assets or company shares, it’s crucial to understand the implications of each approach, conduct thorough due diligence, and work closely with experienced legal and financial advisors.
By carefully structuring the transaction, negotiating key terms, and ensuring a smooth transition, you can minimise risks and set the stage for a successful business acquisition or sale. With the right preparation, guidance, and execution, buying or selling a business can be a rewarding opportunity for growth and success.
